|
Author |
Message |
roadking |
Post subject: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Wed Apr 10, 2013 12:24 am |
|
|
Senior Road Captain |
|
Joined: Thu May 29, 2008 10:11 am Posts: 3632 Location: Orange County, CA |
|
|
So it's getting to be riding season and you and a few others decide to go for a ride on the weekend... It's decided where to meet up and what time... Everyone shows up - tanks topped off - ready to go... OR are you? What's the proper way to get a group of MotorCyclists from point A to point B safely? How do you get everyone on the same page? Do you review procedures or just assume everyone already knows what to do - what about when they all get to a 4 way stop sign? or enter the freeway/highway on ramps, change lanes, ride in formation... yeah the basics - or are they? Maybe I'm just the OCD type personality - I don't care if you've ridden for 100 years - I want to know that you know what to do when the time comes. Pre- ride rider meetings have always been a part of my riding life. I don't care how bad ass the group was - we always made sure we all knew what was expected of us long before the engines started spinning. So how do you do it? I'm hoping to pick up some new tips or offer tips what ever.
The reason is - I've been riding with a new group for the last couple weeks - I did 3 rides with them and the truth is they are really nice people but not very experienced in what they do. Ask them and they are the greatest riders in the world but in truth - not really.
So after the last ride didn't go as planned, I penned a message to the organizer/group lead. I explained what I observed and offered some advice so that future rides will be safer and more organized... It fell on deaf ears. He thinks he's doing a bang up job - and granted his videos are superb but his leadership falls short.
OK - so heres the thing, am I just old school? or is there a right way to do it? We used to go over the rules before each ride - we ride as a group - we stay together - never loose sight of any rider - keep it tight... what else... I had to explain that when you ride in a small group 10 or less that you are supposed to keep the group together like riding on a bus. Stop signs - when the first 2 go, everyone goes... and so on... So some feed back. Lets all have a great summer full of great group rides where we all look professional.
You can have it cheap. You can have it fast. You can have high quality. PICK ANY 2....
|
|
Top |
|
|
thecarpenter |
Post subject: Re: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Wed Apr 10, 2013 5:14 am |
|
Rider |
|
Joined: Tue Dec 13, 2011 12:00 pm Posts: 246 Location: Herrin Illinois |
|
|
I've always avoided group rides of more than two bikes. Last year for the first time I joined a group of four and it was chaos for the first half. My son was one of the riders, before we took off I explained to him what he needed to do for a safe ride. He did great the other two where complete aholes. We where all going to a blessing of the bikes event. halfway through I shot out into the lead and everything went well for the second half. For the trip home I told my son he was welcome to ride with the wife and I but the rest where on there own.
I'm no pro group rider RK but i agree with everything you stated above. In order for everyone to have a safe ride everyone needs to be on the same page.
|
|
Top |
|
|
roadking |
Post subject: Re: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Wed Apr 10, 2013 1:19 pm |
|
|
Senior Road Captain |
|
Joined: Thu May 29, 2008 10:11 am Posts: 3632 Location: Orange County, CA |
|
|
thecarpenter wrote: I've always avoided group rides of more than two bikes. Last year for the first time I joined a group of four and it was chaos for the first half. My son was one of the riders, before we took off I explained to him what he needed to do for a safe ride. He did great the other two where complete aholes. We where all going to a blessing of the bikes event. halfway through I shot out into the lead and everything went well for the second half. For the trip home I told my son he was welcome to ride with the wife and I but the rest where on there own.
I'm no pro group rider RK but i agree with everything you stated above. In order for everyone to have a safe ride everyone needs to be on the same page. I've done the same - avoiding the group rides - but as time goes on riding buddies get married or get old or get hurt - what ever.... You wind up riding everywhere alone - and that gets old pretty quickly. Now I have my girl and she's cool with us just going alone but I know things I don't like to have her thinking about - like what if something goes bad - she thinks she's going to be the one making a call but I know if something happens to me then the same is probably going to happen to her so - when there is at least one other bike there - you have some one to make a call for you. So what I'm getting at is - at some time we/us/all will have an opportunity/commitment to ride in some form of group ride. You did the blessing of the bikes - looking back, what/how would you do differently. Here's my question to everyone:Even if you take 10 minutes and gave everyone a run down - What would be on your list of topics? How would you go about explaining it to them? Hand signals - vary by group - what ones are standard? AND YEAH I AM WRITING A BOOK I'm going to call it: The group riding manual: "How to ride motorcycles in a group safely" written by the seasoned members of Harley Riders Forum. Then we can print it out - hand it out - and everyone is now on the "same page" so to speak. The Pre-Ride Checklist: what's your version?
You can have it cheap. You can have it fast. You can have high quality. PICK ANY 2....
|
|
Top |
|
|
roadking |
Post subject: Re: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Wed Apr 10, 2013 2:08 pm |
|
|
Senior Road Captain |
|
Joined: Thu May 29, 2008 10:11 am Posts: 3632 Location: Orange County, CA |
|
|
I did some research came up with this [youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erpkyD7SMfw[/youtube]
The original is 17 minutes - this version is edited down - why? I don't know... I'm looking for the full version - if someone wants to try to find it the title is "The MSF Guide to Group Riding"
You can have it cheap. You can have it fast. You can have high quality. PICK ANY 2....
|
|
Top |
|
|
harley |
Post subject: Re: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Wed Apr 10, 2013 5:17 pm |
|
Rider |
|
Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2012 6:19 pm Posts: 512 |
|
|
I am not much for safety, common sense I like better. I lead a ride of 19 bikes from Ma. to rolling thunder in DC, and then around DC at night on a tour of memorials and monuments. No one crashed and no one got lost except for a few that did not want to do the whole tour of DC. One rider had a GPS attached to his bars, they left he had the motel plugged in, after a few turns, like enough to not be able to get back he took a turn and the GPS crashed on the ground and broke. we left DC about 2 hours later and beat them back to the motel. Also did an extended ride through the Catskills, some bailed and went straight home from PA, which made all the riders that were left, happy. We had a great 4 day ride along with the events of rolling thunder
DEERSLAYER
|
|
Top |
|
|
badinfluence63 |
Post subject: Re: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Wed Apr 10, 2013 9:34 pm |
|
|
Road Captian |
|
Joined: Sat Oct 23, 2010 9:51 am Posts: 1966 |
|
|
Part I
There is a correct way and it should be dictated by common sense. I've personally been on both ends of the spectrum of excellent, bad and good group riding.
First, worse case scenario...20+ bikes never having ridden together as a group.
This is an actual event. All 20-22 bikes met in Nashville,TN with the destination MArble Falls, Arkansas. When the preferred route was being discussed I tried to encourage taking the interstate because taking the back route takes longer and many small towns in between and which will cause disruption. Nope. The powers that be decided on the back way because riders had voiced a concern about not being comfortable on the interstate.
Despite holding a briefing before the ride it was still a cluster f*ck of sh*t. In the briefing in which I gave, it was stated by me to 1)ride staggered. 2) ride as tight as you feel comfortable yet staying staggered(give the rider ahead of you both sides of the lane at all times for emergent bailout)but do not string out the procession ridiculously. And the various hand signals to be used and what CB channel myself towards the front and the other guy in the back would be using.
I was to the front of the group though not the lead rider. 2 friends high up on the food chain took the first 2 spots. Me in 3rd and another designated route maker in the back had intercom/CB's. We channeled I think 18 or 21 or some mutual number. He would communicate to speed up or to slow down as needed. Sounds bullet proof huh?
The first stage of the ride was luckily about 20 miles, it seemed, of interstate. That went pretty well except the group would string out way more then it should have.
Once off the interstate it turned into a major cluster f*ck of sh*t. Road guards chickend out at the lights leaving a percentage of the group stuck at a red light. The guy in the rear with the head phones would communicate forward for me to find a pull over. The 2 buddies in the front and w/out head gear complained that they couldn't understand why the group was speeding up or slowing down. I explained that if you see me coming up on you speed up, if I drop back slow down.
We did have road guards and we did explain to the group to ride single file after the we were all thru the intersection to allow he RG's to get back in place...never happened.
When we stopped for lunch one of the bigger riders of the 2 in front got all in my face about riding up his ass,lol. And he didn't like it. I said I can fix that...you can ride 3rd now. After lunch and we'd proceeded for another rest the guy who had complained said he new what the problem was..it was him, he was riding in cruise control and that was causing the rest of the group to accordion. Wow...cruise control in a multi bike procession...
We had left at 8am and pulled into the destination like 7:30P.M. Had we taken the interstate we would have been there hours earlier, it would have been an easy 8am-4pm ride. Ultimately it was fun to ride with 20+ bikes on the other hand (shaking head) it got worse as the weekend wore on,lol. I finally just stopped riding with those guys that weekend and for ever more.
Attachments: |
ARK.jpg [ 13.89 KiB | Viewed 8314 times ]
|
To expect to be perfect is unreasonable, to strive for perfection is reasonable. 2015 Ultra Classic Low.
Last edited by badinfluence63 on Wed Apr 10, 2013 10:02 pm, edited 2 times in total.
|
|
Top |
|
|
badinfluence63 |
Post subject: Re: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Wed Apr 10, 2013 9:52 pm |
|
|
Road Captian |
|
Joined: Sat Oct 23, 2010 9:51 am Posts: 1966 |
|
|
Part II
An Excellent group ride. Back in the 80's and early 90's I rode in a club with about 8-10 guys who'd I grown to know very well through spending much time with them on and off the rode. When we road as a group it was side by side at a high rate of speed. At times we would also foolishly reach over and shut the other guys bike off,lol. I know I know....we were in our 20's give me a break.
However when on curvy back roads we automatically new too recind the speed depending which side we were on and which way the curve was going. Back on the straight-a-way it was business as usual. I miss that.
Part III
Can't say I remember ever having a group ride with multiple bikes of having never ridden together before and going well.
A good group ride would be staggered bikes that were not strung out to far because of individual riders shortcomings. I do think its a good idea to have the leader and a rider in the rear to have head sets for communication if there are more then say 8-10 riders. And to remember a procession is only as good as your weakest rider and the speed should lend itself to that weaker rider for safety sake. No room for egoes, pride and other injury producing qualities. Road guards are good if they have the nerve even when the light turns green.
On that same afore mention Marble Falls,AR ride, the next day was a group ride for those of us who came from Nashville and the other riders who were already there..about 35+ bikes. The unofficial "Boss" determined his friend a former dirt bike rider on his first HD would lead the procession thru the Ozarks. What an ahole. He was going so fast that by time the last 5-6 riders caught up they had to go 75-80MPH. In fact we had lost a pack of about 6-8 back in town at a light. And when some one asked the lead rider to please slow down he said "whats a matter you're all to pussy to hang with the big dogs." Once we got back to camp I was done as were a few other riders.
It really is common sense and compassion to have everyone be safe.
To expect to be perfect is unreasonable, to strive for perfection is reasonable. 2015 Ultra Classic Low.
|
|
Top |
|
|
roadking |
Post subject: Re: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Thu Apr 11, 2013 1:06 pm |
|
|
Senior Road Captain |
|
Joined: Thu May 29, 2008 10:11 am Posts: 3632 Location: Orange County, CA |
|
|
Common sense is the basis - I have to agree wholeheartedly. I've had many group rides - the best are always going to be when the group knows each other well and how each other ride. The worst ones are when a bunch of folks that have never ridden together go and no one knows what is going on and there are beginners without a clue mixed in. I went on the latter, 3 times with this new group, I found. Turns out the leader is scared to split lanes and never looks in his rear view mirror. He sets a pace too fast for the beginners to comfortably keep and so the group splits or accordions back and forth. In any case I have to keep a constant watch on whats going on making it very hard to relax and enjoy the ride. I've taken my girl with me on the first 2 rides and went solo the last time. Luckily I went solo the last time because it turned into a cluster fk. No matter how good one is - splitting lanes (which is proven to be safer than sitting in traffic) is still a dicey prospect any way it's sliced. My girl tells me she just closes her eyes when I do it - which tells me it scares the crap out of her. So instead of making her go through that I left her home. Our last outing, the leader - announced earlier in the ride we were going to do a course change and avoid the backed up part of the freeway (about a 40 mile stretch - or basically the reason I left my GF home) and go back along the secondary roads, my favorite. We had one rider in the mix (lets call him... Mark-not his real name) that believed that he was in charge - only problem was - he wasn't. He kept riding up to the front and pulling the group over to let us know he was clueless and lost. The leader of the ride - the one that announced the course change - had the group on course was taking us on the return leg - when "Mark" rode up to the front AGAIN and told the leader to go the original way - 40 miles of backed up freeway - and our hapless leader agreed... WTF??? We sat at the lunch table and all agreed to the revised route then this idiot dictates to the "leader" and he folds like wet tissue paper... Now I could see if "Mark" was a big brute of a man that intimidates with each step - but - here's the kicker - the dude is 5'3 by 4'8... and just a .... "putz". I really had a problem with him and had a talk to him right before lunch. He didn't know how to group ride - and I was going over some basics about 4 way stop signs and the dude basically screamed "Don't Tell Me How To Ride!!!!" - "I've been riding for a long time!!!!"... I wanted him to meet my right glove - with my fist still in it - BUT - I promised my girl I'd play nice - dam it!! I ate my temper - and just said I wanted everyone on the same page - I have video proof of his antics - He must be really good friends of the "leader" that's all i can come up with. Anyway, not five minutes later he did exactly what I was talking about and got the second half of the group stuck... we had 7 bikes total - 4 of us stuck - our "leader" rides away 2 miles and turns off goes 100 yards and then realizes we are not behind them - gets off his bike and starts to walk back towards the corner and wave us down - LUCKILY - I studied the maps and knew the way - because I would have never seen him frantically waving from down the block. Regroup and push on. OK - to err is human - I'm not perfect - although I had a friend that once asked me if I had hemorrhoids? I answered no - and then he said "Oh, then you are a perfect asshole!".... I can see that the organizers are in a little over their heads - I saw it on the first ride - not 10 miles into it the "leader" riding sweep/tail gunner, almost ran into a sand barrel on the freeway. sand barrel Attachment:
Fitch-barrels-on-I-84W.jpg [ 11.64 KiB | Viewed 8277 times ]
I said to him at the first stop - I saw what happened to you in my mirror - I told him it scared the crap out of me... He said "It scared the crap out of you!?! ... It scared the shit out of me!!!!" He then went over to the other organizer - who was leading, and told him to start to make the lane changes 2 miles before the turnoff - making it look - to me - like he was passing the fault on to him for what happened... We all made the turn no problems. I think the "leader" was day dreaming - or he was high... JK I promised myself - I'd give them another chance -we were getting out - going to a few places I haven't been for years and one I've never been to, so I really wanted this to work out. I went on the 2nd ride - more stupid sh&t... riders without a group attitude/actions/lack of common sense... Third time's the charm - cluster fk... So I sent a private message with my observations and some helpful advise - I offered my time and experience to help them. The response was defensive and contradictory - his recollection of our conversations differed from the version myself and my GF (my witness) have. So I've decided that I'll put any differences aside and help them get their act together. It should be fun - and I'll help some folks learn to be better riders. All I wanted was the typical rider meeting - 7 bikes - ok we can do some cool stuff with a small group like that. Easy - Peasy - go over some basic common sense topics and get everyone on the same page - that way we all can enjoy the ride. One thing about group riding I've noticed is - attitude. We are group of individuals attempting to act as one. Unless everyone in that group has that same attitude the concept fails. I find that when riders don't ride with a team understanding - each person in their position is required to act in a predictable and consistent manner the group's safety is risked and that's the reason no one likes riding in groups - and why the pre-ride rider meeting has to incorporate basic proper procedures for group riding.
You can have it cheap. You can have it fast. You can have high quality. PICK ANY 2....
|
|
Top |
|
|
badinfluence63 |
Post subject: Re: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Thu Apr 11, 2013 2:01 pm |
|
|
Road Captian |
|
Joined: Sat Oct 23, 2010 9:51 am Posts: 1966 |
|
|
The whole try to fix it thing didn't work out for me. I was going to quit but there were a few people w/in the group I had come to know and like. So I decided to make a pitch for improvment. I emailed as was advised to keep it private, about all the desparities I had experienced. I got banned for my troubles. The mods took offence. A few members (including one mod who exchanged agreeable emails wth me as well as phone callls,still have the emails) and who I thought were on the same page as me continue to follow blindly because their need to belong to the group out weighed there need or concern for safty and real time propriety. The ones I got along with were long time and experienced riders, left and we stay in touch. The ones that stayed are first time bike owners and the new group cyber experience works for them regardless how squed.
Its too bad cause if we could have worked out the wrinkles it could have been huge. As a consequence of continued business as usual people come and go once they figure out the lay of the land.
Its been a dream of mine to orchestrate a nation wide network of "safe zones" for those of us who ride long distance. You know a place to pitch a tent or even a spare bed. A friendly zone. Perhaps as a nation we are truly to selfish and unable to reach out to this extent.
To expect to be perfect is unreasonable, to strive for perfection is reasonable. 2015 Ultra Classic Low.
|
|
Top |
|
|
roadking |
Post subject: Re: Is there a Correct way to ride in a group Posted: Thu Apr 18, 2013 11:46 am |
|
|
Senior Road Captain |
|
Joined: Thu May 29, 2008 10:11 am Posts: 3632 Location: Orange County, CA |
|
|
I guess my emails must have finally been shared with the organizer of my new group riding club. He just posted 2 different threads on our members board. roadking wrote: Quoted from members board:
Motorcycle (Group) Ride Rules/ Etiquette!! 1) Your first priority must be safety. The fact that you are now riding in a formation should not increase your risk or that of others. For that reason everyone must ride their own ride in a manner that keeps them in their comfort zone. Never exceed your capability or comfort zone just to keep up. If the pace is too quick for you - back off until you feel comfortable. The group will eventually slow to your pace. There is no need to rush to avoid becoming lost or separated from the group
2) Discipline is essential. When riding in a group, you automatically forfeit some personal autonomy. You should normally maintain your relative position within the group unless doing so would compromise safety. Randomly changing positions is an indication of an undisciplined rider, increases risk for everyone else and should not be condoned. There may be times when changing your position in the formation is the safe thing to do. But before you do, you should have a good reason and it shouldn't be frequent.
3) Trust your leader. This is a two-way deal. You should trust your leader and he must be competent to lead. A good leader will always take into account the equipment, experience and skill level of each rider. He needs to tailor his riding accordingly. A common practice I would like to see more of is a concise briefing by the leader just before the ride. Depending on the nature of the ride and the familiarity of those within the group, this briefing may only take a minute or two. As a minimum, the leader should outline the route and establish the overall tone for the ride. Questions should be addressed before the helmets go on.
4) Pay attention and don't assume. This is so basic and elementary that it should not need to be addressed. However, far too many accidents have occurred during group rides where someone just stopped paying attention for a split second and ran into the person in front of them. Be aware of your spacing behind the rider in front in terms of time. Know your own reaction time and stopping capability and don't ride any closer in point of time. Never assume the rider in front will continue at his current pace and never look away for any longer than an instant.
When accelerating from a stop, especially in conjunction with a turn, don't assume the rider in front will continue to accelerate just because his brake light went out and he started to roll. He could subsequently see something that causes him to stop while you are looking over your shoulder for traffic and run into him. Unfortunately, this scenario has also played out all too often.
5) Each rider is directly responsible for the rider behind them. This enhances mutual support. If the rider behind you starts to fall back, so should you. If you lose sight of the person behind you, slow down for a while. If that doesn't work after a period of time - turn around. Something has obviously happened and he probably could use your help. As you can see, if the last person in the formation had his engine quit (ran out of gas) or crashed eventually the entire group would be at his aid. For larger groups the leader should identify smaller units that would stay together for such situations. If it is necessary to stop or if you decide to take a different route, it is essential that someone in the group knows where you are.
A good technique that makes it easy for the guy in front of you to see you is to position yourself so you can see his eyes in his mirror. If you can't see his eyes, he can't see you without moving his head. This is even more applicable if he only has one mirror.
6) Type of formation (staggered, trail, line abreast) and spacing. This depends on your environment (weather, road type and condition, speed, congestion, etc.), and your mission. One extreme would be in heavy stop and go rush-hour traffic at very slow speeds. A close staggered formation with no less than nose/tail clearance (unless stopped) might be the smartest formation. In city traffic a closely spaced formation will discourage cars from "cutting" in. Leave them room and they may be tempted to cut-in. Better to tighten up the spacing a bit so cars perceive the group as a homogeneous unit.
The other extreme would be a "spirited" ride out in the hill country on a twisty open road with no traffic. Here the smart formation might be an extended trail just keeping the guy in front and in back of you in sight.
For me line abreast is strictly a "show" formation suitable for funerals, processions and such and has no place in an informal group ride. It diminishes your margin of error and increases risk of a collision. However, when pulling up to a stop, stopping two abreast is probably a good idea.
Unless briefed otherwise, during the course of a typical informal group ride your position (formation and spacing) should be fluid and dictated by the overall situation. You might find yourself going from a close staggered to an extended trail formation and back again all in a relative short amount of time.
At times you may want to have increased spacing to avoid road hazards like rock chips while at the same time desire to keep the formation relatively tight. Two bikes riding close staggered in trail with other groups of two works well in this case.
Sometimes when on a two-lane road riding staggered and you find yourself on the left track it is a good idea to move over to the right momentarily when on-coming traffic passes. This is especially true for larger vehicles like 18-wheelers. This is to have a little more distance and time in case something falls off; he veers towards you, or throws a "grit blast" in his wake.
7) Establishing the spacing. Because there are so many variables that could dictate the optimum spacing, number two in the formation should normally set the spacing for the group. Nobody else is in a position to logically set or change the spacing in a fluid environment. As such, the number two rider should be experienced and have a solid understanding of group ride dynamics. In city traffic you may need to frequently make minor deviations to the group spacing to avoid running in the blind-spots of other vehicles.
Although you may be number five and can't see number two, you would only need to maintain the spacing that number four has on three. In other words, set your own spacing based on the spacing taken by the guy in front of you. Don't exceed your comfort level in order to maintain spacing.
8) Speed and lanes. It depends. The leader initially sets the pace but eventually the slowest rider should normally determine it. If everyone follows the guidelines above then speed will take care of itself. A modification to this might be on country rides where there is a pre-ride agreement that the faster riders will be in the front of the group and the slower riders in the rear, and that the faster group will wait at all turn-decision points until the second group catches up. A common misconception is that going slower is always safer. Not true. On our superslabs, going slower can get you killed.
b] Keep the group together . The LEADER will Briefing before ride and after. Question should be addressed before the helmets go on or after the ride....was come up to my attention and Jerry....about keep the group together, here what we have to do before and after ride we all have stay in the group until to the point!, after lunch and last stop for gas..please stay in the group together until to the point slip off go home, do not try slip off before it is for safety concern, some of member try to go their own way after ride back home, we here lead the group ride to enjoin not to let get hurt. From now everyone (members) on the ride stay within the group together ride back home, after lunch or last stop for gas... Back home... Please let the lead know in advanced before the helmets go on! some point you slip off go home. My suggestion for who have Bike with less than 2 gallon gas tank!! Be better with short ride it hard for the group ride keep up with small tank of gas; I understand each of us love what you have, but for long ride it can't be done.
The second quote was because I made a fuss about leaving the noob to fend for himself in 40 miles of very heavy traffic - but the leaders left him behind/ and the tail gunner passed him up... As it stands: I may have not fixed the problem completely - but I think I have them working in a better direction now.
You can have it cheap. You can have it fast. You can have high quality. PICK ANY 2....
|
|
Top |
|
|
|
|